Seventh-seeded Florida (26-11) went out in the regional final for the second straight year, with Donovan falling to 0-7 lifetime against the man who coached him at Providence, hired him as an assistant at Kentucky and felt as proud as a papa when he watched Donovan win his two national titles in 2006 and 2007.
This one, however, was no heartwarmer.
Donovan got under Pitino's skin early in the second half during a timeout when he worked over the officials, who promptly called a foul against the Cardinals (30-9) when play resumed.
''He called that,'' Pitino shouted. ''Why don't you just give him a whistle?''
Pitino couldn't get a break for a while after that and when Siva picked up his fourth foul, the coach stomped onto the court and got hit with a technical. Erving Walker made four straight free throws and the Gators led by 11, setting the stage for what could've been Donovan's fourth trip to the Final Four.
But the team that went 8 for 11 from 3-point range in the first half went cold - really cold - not hitting any of nine attempts from beyond the arc in the second.
The Gators missed seven shots and committed one turnover over the last 2:30. They didn't score after Boynton's layup gave them a 68-66 lead with 2:39 left.
The game's best freshman? That was Behanan, who was far less heralded than Beal coming out of high school, but outplayed him down the stretch when the trip to New Orleans was on the line.
The freshman from Cincinnati scored 13 of his 17 points in the second half, including nine over the last 8:02 and Louisville's last two field goals - both after Siva had fouled out with nine points and eight assists.
Beal, meanwhile, finished with 14 points and controlled this game for the first 37 minutes.
But over the last 3, he tried twice to take the ball to the hoop, only to get denied by 6-foot-10 center Gorgui Dieng. Beal missed a desperation 3 in the waning seconds and also got called for traveling after stealing a pass from Smith while Louisville was nursing a one-point lead with 18 seconds left.
Next up for Pitino is a trip to New Orleans for his sixth Final Four. And waiting next Saturday, a possible matchup with his old school, Kentucky, who will have to get by Baylor on Sunday to set up a grudge match to end them all.