It's no secret that every college football program would prefer to play as many home games as they…
Tide, Noles Nuts
Despite these seemingly harmless sanctions which should be more accurately called wrist slaps both institutions are continuing the fight with the powers that be. At FSU the motivation is to keep Bobby Bowden within one win of Joe Paterno in his silly race to be the winningest major college coach of all time. At ‘Bama I'm not certain what the motivation is but I do know this; both schools are making big mistakes.
Instead of burying this issue and moving on Both Florida State and Alabama are ensuring their wrongdoing will remain a public topic of discussion.
As I've written before I don't agree with forfeiture as a punishment by the NCAA and never will. Making believe things that happened didn't really take place is stupid in all situations and particularly so at a supposed institution of higher learning. Scholarship reductions, recruiting limitations and post-season bans will serve as a deterrent to illegal behavior. The threat of eventual forfeiture never has and never will.
There's no doubt the people in charge at both school believe they are doing the right thing, but they're mistaken. The Committee on Infractions tends to dig in its heels when its judgment is challenged. The Seminoles and Crimson Tide would put their resources to better use by sponsoring and pushing legislation that would remove forfeiture as a sanction option in NCAA infractions cases. Such legislation would rid college sports of this inane and ineffective form of "punishment". Of course that will force the Committee to turn to other, more punitive measures, but that's the point. Don't pretend what happened didn't happen. Instead make sure the school where "it" happened pays a severe price for letting "it" take place.
Florida State knew there was something fishy about one particular class long before its internal investigation rooted out all the details. Had the ‘Noles known the penalty for ineligible players competing would be serious scholarship cuts they would have suspended every athlete in that class until they could be cleared. And there's little question Alabama could have been much more aware of what was going on just be looking at the charges on each student-athlete's text book account.
The punishment shouldn't fit the crime. It should exceed the crime. Forfeiture is a counter-productive penalty, but it's better for both schools than scholarships cuts and/or post-season bans. FSU and Alabama should re-direct its efforts and move on from these incidents.
FightinGators.com Recommended Stories
Defense dominates Eastern Kentucky
The Florida defense didn’t give up a first down until the Colonels’ fourth drive of the game, giving the offense time to settle in while the Gators dominated the line of scrimmage.Read More
Dr. Roto Video: Week 12 Key Matchups
Dr. Roto highlights each and every game upcoming for Week 12 and a Fantasy matchup to monitor within. Cleveland Browns WR Josh Gordon (pictured above) makes his return against the less-than-stellar…Read More
Muschamp wouldn’t let them quit
It has never been about effort for Will Muschamp’s teams at Florida. Some have focused on losing a game to Georgia Southern a year ago and how that should never happen and that is a valid point. Some…Read More
Gators bowl eligible with 52-3 win over EKU
The memories of their last game in The Swamp will be sweet for Florida’s 22 seniors and for outgoing head football coach Will Muschamp. Both the seniors and Muschamp started their Florida careers in…Read More
6 Biggest Man-to-Man Rivalries in Sports
From Pierce and Lebron to Peyton and Tom to Ali and Frazier, we're celebrating love/hate on and off the field of play.Read More
- Game Thread: E Kentucky at Florida 11/22 12 p.m. SEC Network
- Mike Gundy Heating up....
- Let me paint you a picture…..Crazy to Think??
- Before you predict anything might want to look at these Salaries
- Hollywood Bob’s Midnight Madness (11/17)